Legacy Tree Logo
Contact Us
  • English
    • Auto
    • Spanish
    • Portuguese (Brazil)
    • Swedish
    • Danish
    • Norwegian Bokmål
    • Russian
Contact Us
  • Services
  • Highlights
  • About
  • Press
  • Blog
  • .
    • English
      • Auto
      • Spanish
      • Portuguese (Brazil)
      • Swedish
      • Danish
      • Norwegian Bokmål
      • Russian

2 Guidelines for Resolving Conflicting Information in Sources

March 11, 2015 by Legacy Tree Genealogists 8 Comments

The conflicting information in sources can be a brick wall in your genealogy search. If or when you run into this unfortunate situation, here's some tips to help resolve those conflicts!

We’ve all beenConflicting Information in Sources there – tracking down an ancestor and finding an answer we've been looking for on a document, only to find another record that says something different!

The death certificate has a different date of death than the headstone, a census gives a different place of birth than a marriage record, and so on. This is a common occurrence in records from earlier time periods when people didn't put as much importance on ages, spellings, etc. as we may now. Do you ever find yourself stuck when this happens, uncertain which one is correct? Next time you hit that wall, follow these two guidelines for dealing with conflicting information. While they aren’t foolproof every single time, they tend to be helpful in most instances.

1) Consider Whether the Record is a Primary or Secondary Source

You may be straining to remember back to sixth grade when your teacher covered those topics in English or history, so here’s a reminder of their definitions: a primary source is a record created at the time of the event described, usually by someone who was a direct participant or witness. Examples could include diaries, letters, photos, or certain government records, like birth certificates. A secondary source is a record created more distantly from the event by someone who wasn’t necessarily there. It may even be an analysis of the event, or someone else’s interpretation of it. For example, the history of a county, a biography, an obituary, and even the birth information on a tombstone would be considered secondary.

The key is generally to put more faith in the source that was created closest to the event and that had the greatest chance of being made by the person it describes, or by a direct relative (like a parent) who would have been present at the time the event occurred.

How does this apply to conflicting sources? Let’s use an example. Suppose your great-grandfather’s headstone said that he was born 6 July 1894, but his World War I draft registration card said he was born 6 June 1895. Obviously one of these is incorrect (or possibly they both are). So, using the guidelines discussed above, which do you think you would be most likely to trust? If you picked the draft card, you’re right on. Think about it: Johnny went before the clerk himself in 1917 to fill out the information on the card. He even signed the bottom of it after reviewing its accuracy. But the headstone? He was already deceased and most likely had no input about what went on it. And if Johnny was 85 when he died, what are the chances that someone is still around who was there at his birth, and that was the person who provided the information for his tombstone? Not very likely. In this instance, perhaps the informant was an in-law who wasn’t sure of his exact date. Maybe the man carving the stone had written the date down incorrectly. Perhaps the grieving widow in her stress and anguish had simply misspoken. Either way, there is a much greater chance that this record is the incorrect one.

2) Look for Additional Sources

If you find two records that both say something different about your ancestor, go in search of more records. In the example above, you've got a headstone and a WWI draft card. Can you find a birth record? A marriage record? The 1900 U.S. Census which gave the month and year of birth for each person? In order to resolve conflicting information, it's important to look for all available sources that would have listed that information. Chances are you'll notice a pattern eventually. Five records might all list one thing, while only one or two list something else. In this case, you'll still want to evaluate primary vs. secondary, but if even your primary sources are conflicting, you can choose to go with the majority.

A final example from a recent project we researched: a client’s ancestor had been famous during her lifetime – well-known enough to have newspaper articles written about her all over the country. Every single one of them said that she had been born in a fashionable neighborhood in an East Coast American city. Even her own son had been told she was born there. The truth turned out to be far different when we discovered her original birth certificate in a city on the opposite side of the United States, where she had grown up. The newspapers were 3,000 miles wrong – every one of them. Why did we go with the birth certificate rather than five different newspapers all saying the same thing? Because there are many reasons why a newspaper article written by a journalist could be incorrect or misled – but there really isn’t a chance a county registrar would arbitrarily create a birth certificate for someone who wasn’t actually born there. In this specific case, the woman herself probably had incentive to polish her past in an effort to make it seem more exciting since she was a celebrity, but the truth was in the courthouse records in California.

The bottom line is, take your time! Find as many sources as possible, and then consider when and where they were created, and by whom. By doing this, you should be able to confidently resolve many of the discrepancies you'll find while researching your ancestors.

The experts at Legacy Tree Genealogists are here to help you connect with your ancestors and preserve your legacy for generations to come. Get started today by requesting your free quote.

 

Are you finding a record with conflicting information? Follow these two guidelines for dealing with conflicting information in genealogy sources.

Filed Under: Methodology Tagged With: center, conflicting, Documents, help, information, library, methodology, primary, research, resolving, resources, secondary, sources

About the Author

blank
Legacy Tree Genealogists
The team at Legacy Tree Genealogists has been helping clients worldwide discover their roots for 20 years. We're based near the world's largest Family History Library and connected with genealogists and archives around the world, and we love doing what we do! We also love sharing our genealogy tips with our readers.

Comments

  1. Jane says

    March 12, 2015 at 12:40 am

    grest informstion

    Reply
  2. Larry Garland says

    March 12, 2015 at 8:34 am

    Very interesting article. Great job.

    Reply
  3. Allison - Legacy Tree Genealogists Project Manager says

    March 12, 2015 at 10:36 am

    When researching, I often come across conflicting information and these two guidelines are very useful ideas for resolving discrepancies. I especially appreciated your idea to notice patterns in the records while evaluating their classification as a primary or secondary source.

    Reply
  4. Roni says

    March 12, 2015 at 1:47 pm

    Really LOOK at the record too. I have an instance where the death record names her step-father as her father. Obviously, given that her last name at birth (and that of her sister) didn’t match the step-fathers, it couldn’t be possibly be accurate.

    Reply
  5. Su Lynn says

    April 13, 2015 at 5:05 pm

    thank you! Great article…and may clear up my grandfather’s birthdate! I need to really go back and review the 1900 census for several of my issues.

    Reply
    • blankJessica - Legacy Tree Genealogists President says

      April 13, 2015 at 8:22 pm

      Wonderful! We’re glad it was helpful!

      Reply
  6. Ed Keough says

    December 5, 2020 at 7:23 pm

    On census records I always look at the original. I have seen way too many transcription errors in my research. They see “L”, but if you study the handwriting, you might observe that the person always wrote their “I” or “F”, or some other letter. Don’t be hasty, study it, compare letters, and numbers all over the page.
    Even on old typewritten pages, and a softly hit “F” may appear to be a “T”.
    If you still can’t decide, keep looking for more records to figure out what it is.

    Reply
    • Legacy Tree Genealogists says

      December 7, 2020 at 9:31 am

      Excellent advice, thank you, Ed!

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

REQUEST A FREE QUOTE

    Popular Posts

    Icelandic village

    4 Key Steps to Trace Your Icelandic-Canadian Ancestry

    December 31, 2024 By Rachel Whiting Leave a Comment

    How To Use Orthodox Baptismal Records for Genealogy Research

    November 13, 2024 By Linda - Researcher with Legacy Tree Genealogists 2 Comments

    Babies Left Behind: researching unknown G.I. fathers in the United Kingdom during WW2

    November 5, 2024 By Maggie - Legacy Tree Genealogists Research Team Manager 3 Comments

    How To Understand German Handwriting and Gothic Scripts

    July 2, 2024 By Keri - Legacy Tree Genealogists Researcher Leave a Comment

    Intro to German Genealogy: Practical Tips for Family History Research

    April 23, 2024 By Legacy Tree Genealogists 6 Comments

    Italian Heritage Travel: The My Bella Vita Experience

    April 9, 2024 By Legacy Tree Genealogists Leave a Comment

    German parish records

    3 Essential Websites for Exploring German Parish Records

    August 16, 2023 By Legacy Tree Genealogists 7 Comments

    CATEGORIES

    SEARCH

    NEWSLETTER

    • Home
    • Services
    • Highlights
    • About
    • Blog
    • Contact
    • FAQ
    • Careers
    How to Hire a Professional Genealogist
    Terms of Use Privacy Policy

    © 2004 - 2025 Legacy Tree Genealogists. All rights reserved.

    Cookie Consent

    This site uses cookies to enhance your experience. Consent allows us to track browsing data. Opting out may affect functionality.

    Functional Always active
    Storage or access necessary for enabling the use of services requested by the user, or for the sole purpose of communication over an electronic network.
    Preferences
    Storage or access necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the user.
    Statistics
    Storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
    Marketing
    Storage or access required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
    Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
    Preferences
    {title} {title} {title}
    Cookie Consent

    This site uses cookies to enhance your experience. Consent allows us to track browsing data. Opting out may affect functionality.

    Functional Always active
    Storage or access necessary for enabling the use of services requested by the user, or for the sole purpose of communication over an electronic network.
    Preferences
    Storage or access necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the user.
    Statistics
    Storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
    Marketing
    Storage or access required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
    Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
    Preferences
    {title} {title} {title}